Enhanced flow for your arteries

Planning efforts over the last 30 years or so have concentrated on reducing the number of intersections and curb cuts onto arterial roads. Anyone familiar with US 1 north of Boston knows why.

At the same time, alleyways have been planned out of existence.

These two things, working from opposite directions, have resulted in arterial roads which are scaled to be more like interstate highways than local roads — both in content and their nodes (intersections). The distortion of a what was once a neighborly, pedestrian scale is felt all the way down to the front drives of many — little human scale interaction is achieved  in many approaches to the typical american suburban home. Our cars have become in some instances literal extensions of our homes, as we dock them into garages which open directly into our living spaces.

I digress. To the issue of scale and movement is linked an important point I have made before. In a distributed grid, it would be wrong to have a driveway — a curb cut, in effect a mini-intersection — for each lot. Shepherdstown does not allow driveways along street frontage for a reason. This is where the alley becomes important.

Alleys enable traffic flow in the distributed grid to occur with the same efficient distribution of intersections as arterial roads. The constriction of individual vehicles/ways is restricted to the alley where flow is not important.

But we do need coagulation

While increased arterial flow is good, we don’t want to bleed to death — or have such traffic flow that impedes or even prevents the sensible maintenance of other systems. For both our blood and traffic flow, we need something to keep things in check. Our blood coagulates so we do not bleed to death and pressure is kept in check for good health. We must do the same for traffic. If you’ve heard some discuss traffic calming this is its essence. Accidents, especially serious accidents, are kept in check as speed is kept in check and alertness is raised.

Roads can be designed to calm traffic and enhance alertness. Anyone who has found themselves at the end of an “unfair” speeding ticket might already have sensed that something else aside revenue seeking municipalities at work — the road itself might have contributed to the excess speed. It was designed for it.

One of my favorite traffic calming efforts I’ve seen is the tree planted in the center of a road in Denmark. Speed bumps are a favorite of the DC metro area. One of the easiest and with an additional benefit? On street parking.

Roundabouts in West Virginia

The recent presentation regarding the proposed pedestrian underpass for Shepherd University was thorough and encouraged, in particular with regard to the manner in which the audience relayed their approval or concerns regarding the project.

After the meeting , I had a chance to briefly speak with the engineer for the project, a representative of the WV State Department of Highways and a representative of the university to relay the thoughts I had already conveyed in writing here and emphasize two very important points:

  1. That the character of Shepherdstown suffers when highway-scaled projects are added to the perimeter of the town. The underpass, as proposed, will be an element which does not mix well with the nearby town-scape scale of the  Shepherdstown grid. Instead, its scale is more in keeping with our inelegant Potomac River bridge.
  2. That the State Department of Transportation (WVDOT), as a participant in the pedestrian underpass, should not look at projects such as this myopically. Like an intersection redesign, consideration needs to be give to what happens up and down stream.

These two things are related, of course and a number of the concerns at the meeting did touch upon these ideas — as did the positive review of the adjacent homeowner most affected by the change.

My conversation after the meeting ended abruptly though as I delved deeper into how the proposed detour is suggestive of  the pattern of a traffic circle, which I outlined as an opportunity to solve one of the problems with the existing intersection and clam traffic on Rt. 480. In trying to relate how this traffic circle solution might function by building upon my own experiences, I started to mention observations of roundabouts in France and New England. This was already after a nod to Ranson.

I say I started because I did not get past the word France when I was interrupted by the gentleman from WVDOT stating, “This is America”. Playing the “America” card was, for all intents and purposes in this discussion, the equivalent to Godwin’s law.

Not being one to generate effective and pithy responses in these moments, I ended the conversation. Before that, points had already been made that West Virginia is not ready for traffic circles — the message being that WVDOT has no energy to devote to thinking in a macro view and that moving cars without interference by pedestrians is more important.

A quick rant to my brother about the conversation resulted in gold. I present, for your entertainment, two items regarding traffic circles which are presented on the West Virginia Department of Highways website:

http://gis.wvdot.com/gti/fhwa09planconf/roundabouts.pdf

http://youtu.be/-_m8HzKTZK8

Old Martinsburg Pike

One of the surprises in my most recent sketches for the west side of Shepherdstown came about with the extension of West Washington Street all the way to the new firehall.

Where the extension lands at the western end, is where old Martinsburg Pike deviated from its current course. Good stuff, that.